Subject and Structure
Can you discern the subject of the poem?
Does the title tell you something about the subject of the poem?
Do the lyric components (form and structure, rhyme, meter) of the poem make sense or are they confusing?
Do the layout and line breaks enhance or distract from the flow and meaning of the poem?
Writing Quality and Language
Is there use of clichés / overused words?
When used does the poet demonstrate effective use of
metaphor
alliteration
assonance
rhythm
voice
allegory
Consistency in use of internal images? Themes, motifs
Language
Is the language appropriate and clear? Are there too many adjectives and adverbs?
Does the language show, not tell? Use of sensory references – sound, smell, taste, touch
Do you get the message of the poem?
What does the poem convey to you personally?
How does this writing effect you emotionally/spiritually?
Based on Critiquing Poetry, https://www.writing-world.com/poetry/print/crit.shtml
Thank you to Patricia Tiffany Morris for her editing.